I’ve been asked by several people to provide feedback about Russell Beattie and Mike Rowehl shuttering Mowser. So, I’m just going to post something on our blog rather than respond to everyone individually.
Let me first say that it’s too easy to jump on the pile without first acknowledging those guys’ bravery. It takes a lot of guts to put it all on the line. I really hope they land on their feet.
That said, the Mobile Web is not dead. Are those who are claiming it serious? That’s a preposterous and naive position; it’s just getting started. Contrary to what Russ has put out there about this space, Skweezer has had many successes. And our company continues to innovate and execute in a very steady, patient manner. This is a nascent market, not a dead one.
There are some other invalid assumptions being raised as well–that some people think transcoding is: unnecessary, without a business model, or just plain “easy” to do. Russell represents this in one of his posts on how a transcoder works. Just add Mowser to the other Skweezer clones who thought along those lines (baresite, IYHY, et al) as well.
There’s a fundamental problem with the implementation strategy of leveraging open-source: to do a proper transcoder—and to do it well—these projects only get you about 80% of the way there. Then, that last 20%… is extremely difficult. All of a sudden issues of security, scalability, localization, private-labeling, new feature implementation, personalization, liability, etc. rear their ugly head. And this is what separates the men from the boys. As an example, Yahoo (Novarra), AOL (InfoGin), Mowser and Google can’t even support SSL in their mobile transcoding (Skweezer does). I’m telling you, this isn’t as easy as it looks, folks!
Aside from the Google’s and the Yahoo’s of the world, new entrants like Mowser will always be at a disadvantage because we’ve put in the time, energy, and money LONG AGO. Here are some of the milestones:
- Skweezer firsts…
- Skweezer invented; patent filed (2001)
- Portal-based transcoding engine: Skweezer (2003)
- Globally distributed mobile ad platform: Skweezer Ads (2004)
- Pagination system that splits large Web pages up for viewing on cell phones (2005)
- Mobile Web page translation feature (2005)
- Portal-based mobile RSS reader (2005)
- “Find in page” search that carries Web search keywords into search result pages (2007)
- Awards and Honors…
- 2007 Smartphone & Pocket PC Magazine’s Best Software Awards: Winner - Pocket PC Internet: Web Compression Service
- 2007 MobileVillage Mobile Star Awards: Gold Star - Consumer Software: Mobile Web Content Aggregator / Portal
- 2007 MobileVillage Mobile Star Awards: Gold Star - Enterprise Software: Mobile Marketing
- 2007 MobileVillage Mobile Star Awards: Gold Star - Visionary: Wireless Services (Skweezer founders Kevin Perkins and Mark Sieve)
- 2007 PDA Friendly Website Awards: Winner - PDA Home Page
- 2006 MobileVillage Mobile Star Awards: Gold Star - Personal Software: Mobile Web Content Provider
- 2005 MobileVillage Mobile Star Awards: Gold Star - Personal Software: Mobile Web Content Provider
Forgive the commercial, but I bring it up only to illustrate that—even with all the goodness—it still only represents 50% of the game. The other half is the execution of the innovation, delivered in a simple and clear way, that enables business partners to monetize mobile traffic. Unfortunately, Mowser failed to deliver on that statement. Running interstitials between pages killed the user experience despite the glowing praises of bloggers, who were undoubtedly motivated by commissions from Mowser’s Affiliate Linking Program. (”Find Mowser through me, and I get a rev share of whatever ads get clicked!”)
So, is Mowser’s death also the death of the Mobile Web? Hardly. Matthew Miller raises a number of key points why the Mobile Web will continue on. One thing that I’d like to add to Matthew’s “environment-optimized, one Web” notion… is that there’s a bigger picture here than just “desktop” and “mobile”. As “Web” content finds its way outside of these environments more and more (handheld games, cars, SMS, etc), users and publishers will need a solution that will continue to provide semantic access to content while providing publishers with tools to monetize this activity.
Such is Skweezer.
Posted by Kevin Perkins